Overtime pay is the premium wage owed for qualifying extra hours; under the federal FLSA, covered nonexempt employees earn at least 1.5 times their regular rate for every hour over 40 in a workweek. On shift-based teams, where one extra close or covered call-out can tip someone past 40, it is among the most controllable drivers of labor cost.
- 40 hours, one workweek. Federal overtime is counted per fixed workweek, never averaged.
- Regular rate, not posted rate. Nondiscretionary bonuses can raise the rate overtime is based on.
- Unapproved overtime is still owed. You can enforce a policy, but you must pay for the hours.
- States can add more. California, for example, also requires daily overtime.
When overtime pay is owed
Under the federal overtime rules, covered nonexempt employees must receive at least time and one-half their regular rate for hours worked over 40 in a workweek. Weekends, holidays, and long days do not trigger federal overtime on their own (DOL Fact Sheet #23).
How to calculate overtime pay
- Total the workweek. Use approved timecards, not the schedule.
- Split the hours. Hours 1–40 are regular; everything above 40 is federal overtime.
- Find the regular rate. Usually the hourly wage, adjusted for any nondiscretionary bonus earned that week.
- Apply the premium. Pay overtime hours at 1.5 × the regular rate.
- Check state rules. Add any daily or other overtime your state requires.
When a bonus changes the overtime rate
The regular rate includes most nondiscretionary pay, such as attendance or production bonuses promised in advance (DOL Fact Sheet #56A). Truly discretionary bonuses and gifts are excluded.
Using the posted $20 rate would pay a $20 premium instead of $22. Small on one check, but it adds up to real back pay across a team and a year.
Overtime habits to keep and to drop
Do this
Habits that keep overtime accurate
- Check weekly hours before you publish the schedule.
- Count every hour worked, including early starts.
- Pay overtime on the regular payday for the period it was earned.
Avoid this
Habits that lead to back pay
- Averaging two weeks of hours in a biweekly pay period.
- Offering time off later instead of overtime pay at a private business.
- Ignoring bonuses when setting the overtime rate.
Paid time off is not hours worked, so it generally does not count toward the federal 40, though a policy or state rule can be more generous. For budgeting, fold the premium into your labor cost plan.
Overtime pay FAQs
How do you calculate overtime pay?
Multiply the employee's regular rate by 1.5, then by the hours worked over 40 in the workweek. Add that to pay for the first 40 hours to get gross pay.
Do I have to pay overtime I did not approve?
Yes. If a nonexempt employee worked the hours, you owe the overtime. You can enforce an approval policy through discipline, but not by withholding pay.
Is working on a weekend or holiday automatically overtime?
Not under federal law. The FLSA looks only at hours over 40 in the workweek, though a state rule, contract, or company policy can require more.
How Teamsly helps with overtime pay
Teamsly shows overtime coming before the schedule goes out, and flags it when it happens anyway.
Overtime you can see coming
What each step looks like in Teamsly.
See how AI auto scheduling saves managers hours while keeping overtime in check.
Spot overtime before you publish
Build a week and watch the overtime warnings in the live demo, or start free with no credit card.
Reviewed November 2026 by the Teamsly team. Product details reflect Teamsly feature pages at the time of review. General information, not legal or payroll advice.